Home News & Reviews Editor Obsessions I’m a Beauty Editor – These Are the Best Eye Creams for Mature Skin

I’m a Beauty Editor – These Are the Best Eye Creams for Mature Skin

The best eye creams to shop for every budget.

All products featured on Beautify.tips are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

best eye creams
Courtesy of Brands

Navigating the world of eye creams can feel a lot like trying to decipher a complex map without a compass. As a beauty editor, I’ve swiped, dabbed, and patted my way through myriad jars and tubes, all promising to rejuvenate the delicate eye area. When it comes to mature skin, the stakes are even higher—we’re not just looking for hydration, we’re seeking products that support our skin’s evolving needs.

Why the Eye Area Needs Special Care

The skin around our eyes is the thinnest on our body, making it especially vulnerable to a host of skin concerns like dryness, puffiness, dark circles, and the fine lines affectionately known as crow’s feet. Each of these issues is a natural part of aging, reflecting our joys, sorrows, and the beauty of a life well-lived. Yet, it’s perfectly normal to seek eye creams that help us look as refreshed and vibrant on the outside as we feel on the inside.

Best Eye Creams for Mature Skin

Whether you’re looking for a touch of luxury or a practical daily solution, these products help ensure your eyes—just like your spirit—remain as lively and expressive as ever.

1. Nassif MD Age Defying Eye Renewal Serum ($60, nassifmd.com)

best eye creams

This powerhouse product by Dr. Paul Nassif, renowned from the TV show “Botched,” goes beyond mere moisturizing. Formulated with a mix of peptides and antioxidants, it tackles puffiness and dark circles while enhancing firmness. What makes it stand out is the advanced hexapeptide that helps expression lines appear softer and less prominent while also helping the skin look more radiant.

2. Philosophy Dose of Wisdom Dark Circle Brightening Eye Cream ($56, Ulta)

best eye creams

Philosophy’s Dose of Wisdom Eye Cream is a standout for those specifically battling dark circles. This cream utilizes niacinamide and vitamin C, two ingredients renowned for their brightening and skin-strengthening effects. The addition of caffeine helps to reduce the appearance of puffiness, while hyaluronic acid deeply hydrates and plumps up the under-eye area. It’s a thoughtful blend that targets the key concerns of mature skin, ensuring your eyes look as enlightened as they feel.

3. Olay Regenerist Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream  ($24.94, Walmart)

best eye creams

Olay’s eye cream combines two of the most powerful ingredients in skincare: retinol and niacinamide. Retinol speeds up cell turnover, helping to reduce fine lines and wrinkles, while niacinamide improves skin elasticity and barrier function. This product is a great nightly treatment to help rejuvenate the eye area gently and effectively.

4. La Mer The Eye Concentrate ($229.50. Macys.com)

best eye creams

If you’re looking to indulge, La Mer’s The Eye Concentrate is a splurge-worthy contender. Its key ingredient, Miracle Broth™, is known for its healing and regenerative properties. (I have tried many pricey products before, and this  luxury brand is one of my beauty editor ‘holy grails’.) Ideal for those who not only want to address signs of aging but also enjoy a luxurious skincare ritual, this cream diminishes lines and improves clarity with a velvety touch.

5. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream ($23.49, CVS)

best eye creams

This budget-friendly option you can easily scoop up on your next CVS run from Neutrogena offers hyaluronic acid, which acts like a sponge to draw moisture into the skin’s surface, providing intense hydration and plumping out fine lines. Perfect for those who prefer a lighter texture, it absorbs quickly, making it an excellent base for makeup.


author avatar
Janene Mascarella